Calculation Methodology

How every number on this site is produced — and what the calculators do not capture.

Last updated

All calculators share one TypeScript calculation library. The same code produces the examples in our articles, so text and tools agree. The library has automated tests with expected values computed independently (by closed-form formulas or published IRS figures).

1. Growth projections

Projections use an explicit period-by-period cash-flow simulation. For each contribution period: add the deposit (if at the start), apply the periodic return, add the deposit (if at the end). Contributions can rise each year by a fixed percentage and can be capped at the annual IRA limit for the saver's age.

rperiod = (1 + rannual)1/p − 1  ·  FV = P(1+r)n + PMT[((1+r)n − 1)/r] (× (1+r) if deposits are at the start)
  • Return convention. The "expected annual return" is an effective annual rate. It is converted to an equivalent rate per contribution period so that 12 monthly periods compound to exactly the annual rate.
  • Compounding (compound interest calculator). A nominal rate i compounded m times a year becomes an effective rate (1 + i/m)m − 1, or ei − 1 when continuous.
  • Zero and negative returns. A 0% return is handled without division. Negative returns down to −20% are allowed for stress tests.
  • Inflation. Real values divide the nominal balance by (1 + inflation)years.
  • Rounding. No intermediate rounding; values are rounded only for display.
  • Optimism warnings. Returns above 10% trigger a caution, and above 12% a stronger one.

2. Savings goal

The ending balance is a linear function of the first-year contribution, so the required contribution is solved exactly from two simulations: c = (Goal − B(0)) ÷ (B(1) − B(0)), where B(x) is the ending balance with a first-year contribution of x. Goals in today's dollars are inflated by (1 + inflation)years.

3. Payouts and retirement income

Withdrawals are taken at the start of each month, rising each year by the chosen increase, with the remaining balance growing at the monthly equivalent of the annual return. The sustainable payout is solved exactly (the ending balance is linear in the payout). "How long will it last" runs the schedule forward until the balance is exhausted, up to 60 years.

4. Rate of return

  • CAGR: (End ÷ Start)1/n − 1. Valid only without cash flows.
  • Money-weighted (IRR): the rate i solving Start(1+i)T + Σ Ct(1+i)T−t = End, found by bisection between −99% and +1,000%.
  • Time-weighted: the geometric linking of yearly holding-period returns Vt ÷ (Vt−1 + Ct) − 1, annualized.

5. Contribution limits and income phase-out

Limits come from a year-by-year rules dataset (tax years 2025, 2026, 2027). The Roth limit follows IRS Publication 590-A Worksheet 2-2: the age-based limit is reduced in proportion to MAGI's position in the phase-out range, rounded up to the next $10, with a $200 minimum when any contribution is allowed. The result is further limited to taxable compensation (joint compensation under the spousal IRA rule) and to the shared IRA limit minus traditional IRA contributions for the year.

6. Tax estimates

  • Roth vs traditional: equal annual contributions; traditional balances are reduced by a flat retirement tax rate (only above basis if nondeductible); optional investment of the deduction's tax savings in a taxable account whose return is reduced by a tax-drag percentage.
  • Conversions: the taxable portion follows the pro-rata rule (basis ÷ (year-end value of all traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs + conversion)). Federal tax is the difference in bracket tax with and without the conversion, using IRS brackets for single and joint filers. State tax is a flat rate.
  • Withdrawals: IRS ordering rules (contributions, then conversions first-in-first-out with the taxable part first, then earnings). The qualified-distribution five-year period counts from January 1 of the first Roth tax year; each conversion has its own five-year period for the 10% additional tax. Income tax on taxable earnings uses the marginal rate entered.

7. Known limitations

  • Returns are constant; sequence-of-returns risk and volatility are not simulated.
  • Fees are not deducted unless reflected in the return you enter.
  • Future IRS limits are held at the latest verified level.
  • Tax estimates exclude credits, deductions that phase out, the net investment income tax, Social Security taxation, Medicare IRMAA, and most state rules.
  • Head of household and married filing separately brackets are not yet included in the conversion calculator.

8. Testing

Automated tests cover zero and negative returns, zero contributions, long and very short horizons, deposit timing, contribution caps, inflation adjustment, phase-out boundaries (at, inside and above each range), the $10 rounding and $200 minimum, compensation limits, spousal IRAs, the shared IRA limit, bracket tax against IRS-published tax amounts, pro-rata conversions, and each branch of the withdrawal ordering rules.

IRS rules last verified November 13, 2026.