Roth vs Traditional IRA Calculator

Pay tax now or later? Compare the after-tax value of a Roth IRA and a deductible traditional IRA using your current and expected retirement tax rates, and find the break-even rate where the choice stops mattering.

Estimates use your assumptions and are not guaranteed returns or tax advice.

Compare your options

$
The same dollar amount goes into either IRA.
%
%
Federal + state marginal rate.
%
Expected rate on withdrawals.
%
Share of returns lost to taxes outside an IRA.

After-tax value at withdrawal

Traditional IRA comes out ahead by
$23,290
Break-even retirement tax rate: 18.1%
Roth IRA (after tax)
$758,048

Contributions taxed now; qualified withdrawals tax-free.

Traditional IRA + invested savings (after tax)
$781,338

$758,048 gross, $644,341 after tax, plus $136,997 in taxable savings.

These results depend heavily on tax rates no one can know in advance. Use the break-even rate as the key insight: if you expect your retirement rate to be above it, the Roth is favored.

How to Use the Roth vs Traditional Calculator

  1. Enter the amount you plan to contribute each year and how long it will stay invested.
  2. Enter your marginal tax rate today (the rate on your last dollars of income) and your best guess for retirement.
  3. Decide whether the traditional contribution is deductible and whether you would invest the tax you save.
  4. Compare the two after-tax totals and note the break-even retirement tax rate.

How the Calculation Works

Both accounts receive the same annual contribution at the start of each year and grow at the same return. The Roth balance is spendable in full (assuming qualified distributions). The traditional balance is reduced by your retirement tax rate; for nondeductible contributions, only the earnings above your basis are taxed.

If the traditional contribution is deductible and you invest the savings, the tax you save each year (contribution × today's rate) goes into a taxable account. Its return is reduced by the tax-drag percentage to reflect taxes on dividends and gains.

Roth = FV(C)
Traditional = FV(C) × (1 − tretire) + FV(C × tnow, r × (1 − drag))
Break-even tretire = (FV(C) + Side − Roth) ÷ FV(C)

With no tax drag, the math shows a classic result: when tax rates now and later are equal, the two accounts produce the same after-tax value.

Calculation Examples

$7,500/year for 30 years at 7%, 22% tax rate today, deductible, savings not invested
Retirement tax rateRoth after taxTraditional after taxAhead
10%$758,048$682,243Roth
12%$758,048$667,082Roth
22%$758,048$591,277Roth
24%$758,048$576,116Roth
32%$758,048$515,473Roth

When the tax savings are not invested, the Roth wins at every retirement tax rate above 0% in this example, because the same $7,500 contribution buys more after-tax money in a Roth. Investing the savings is what makes the traditional IRA competitive.

Important Assumptions and Limitations

  • Future tax rates are unknown and laws change. Test several retirement rates.
  • A single flat retirement rate is used; in reality withdrawals fill several brackets and can affect taxation of Social Security and Medicare premiums.
  • Required minimum distributions from traditional IRAs, and their absence from Roth IRAs, are not modeled.
  • Contributing the same dollar amount to a Roth uses more of your annual IRA limit in "after-tax" terms — an advantage for people who can max out.

Applicable IRA Rules

Roth and traditional IRA contributions share one annual limit ($7,500 for 2026). Roth contributions have income limits; traditional contributions do not, but their deductibility phases out if you or your spouse are covered by a workplace plan. If you are married and only your spouse is covered, the 2026 deduction phase-out is $242,000–$252,000. To move existing traditional money into a Roth, see the conversion calculator; for a fuller comparison, read Roth IRA vs traditional IRA.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a Roth or traditional IRA better?

Neither is better for everyone. If your tax rate in retirement will be higher than today, a Roth usually comes out ahead; if it will be lower, a deductible traditional IRA often does — especially if you invest the tax savings. Equal rates produce nearly identical results in a simplified model.

Why does investing the tax savings matter?

A deductible traditional contribution lowers your tax bill today. The fair comparison assumes you invest that saving. If you spend it instead, the traditional IRA loses much of its advantage.

Can I contribute to both a Roth and a traditional IRA?

Yes, but the 2026 limit of $7,500 ($8,600 at 50+) is shared across both. Splitting contributions is one way to diversify your future tax exposure.

Is my traditional IRA contribution deductible?

If neither you nor your spouse is covered by a workplace plan, it is fully deductible. If you are covered, the deduction phases out — for 2026, between $81,000 and $91,000 of MAGI for single filers and $129,000 and $149,000 for joint filers.

What about required minimum distributions?

Traditional IRAs require minimum distributions starting at age 73 (75 for people born in 1960 or later). Roth IRAs have none for the original owner, which this simplified comparison does not value.

Sources and Methodology

Content reviewed November 13, 2026 · IRS limits verified November 13, 2026 · How we calculate · Editorial policy

Calculators provide educational estimates based on user-selected assumptions, not guaranteed investment outcomes or personalized financial advice. Investment returns are uncertain and can be negative. Tax rules depend on facts this site does not collect; confirm your situation with IRS publications or a qualified tax professional. RothMath is not affiliated with the Internal Revenue Service. Read the full disclaimer.